5 soy sauces that deserve permanent spots in your pantry (2024)

If there is one East Asian staple that you can find in practically anyone’s refrigerator or pantry, it’s soy sauce. The salty condiment, hailing originally from China, is a meal-time must-have for dipping, seasoning, and/or marinating.

Australian chef Louis Tikaram is no stranger to the wonders of the fermented liquid. After all, he integrated it into his dishes at Tetsuya’s (Japanese), Lograin (Thai), EP&LP (Modern Asian) and now Stanley — his waterfront Cantonese gem, perched just above the Howard Smith Wharves in Brisbane.

“Soy sauce is such an incredibly diverse ingredient,” he says, alluding to its versatility of use, type and origin. While soy sauce is most commonly associated with Chinese and Japanese cuisines, unique variations can also be found in countries like Korea, Indonesia and Thailand.

Though picking a favorite may seem impossible (especially because different types are used for different dishes), Tikaram offers a few pieces of advice the next time you’re in the grocery store or perusing the internet:

  1. Identify its purpose. “Japanese use soy sauce (shoyu) more as a condiment. It is very subtle and delicate and it can be made to a very high quality from aging and using premium ingredients. Thai soy sauce is used to season curries and stir fries. It is very flavorful and rich. Chinese soy sauce is used for a lot of marinades and sauces. It is powerful and strong and perfect for the intense combinations of ingredients like chili and Sichuan peppercorns.”
  2. Pick between light and dark varieties. “Light soy sauce is saltier and adds a punch. Dark soy sauce is aged for longer, so it is much darker, sweeter, thicker and less salty, though fuller in flavor. I like to add a splash of dark soy sauce to my noodle dishes to give it that great gloss and deep color.”
  3. Consider gluten-free options. “I like to buy soy sauce that is gluten-free so that it contains no wheat. The flavor is not so overpowering, as it’s usually aged longer and makes a good all-around soy sauce for dipping to stir-fries.”

Check out our top picks below, as well as answers to frequently asked soy sauce questions after the jump.

Best Overall: Silver Swan Soy Sauce

The swan may be silver, but the medal is gold for Silver Swan soy sauce from the Philippines. Thanks to its versatility, balance and touch of sweetness, it can be used in endless Asian dishes, from sushi and stir-fry to adobo and ramen. Best of all, it’s available in family-sized jugs so that you can save on money and the inevitable trip to the grocery store after it’s used up in only a week or two.

Best Value: Kikkoman Less Sodium Soy Sauce

Kikkoman is proof that some classics can actually withstand the test of time. It’s also proof that a soy sauce with lower sodium content can taste as delicious as its saltier counterparts. America’s most popular bottle is brewed using the same techniques as any ol’ sauce, but nearly 40% of the salt is removed after fermentation. That means you get all of the body and characteristics found in a standard soy sauce, but with a blend that’s healthier for your blood pressure. Kikkoman recommends using the green bottle in the later stages of cooking to bring out flavors, but it’s just as good on its own or as the foundation of a dipping sauce.

Best Dark: Yamaroku Tsuru Bisiho Soy Sauce

Aged for four years to achieve its signature sweet and rich taste, Yamaroku’s Tsuru Bishiho has developed a cult-like following for those seeking a more gourmet soy sauce experience. By using the saishikomi method, which returns fresh soy sauce to the aging barrel after being fortified with additional soybeans and wheat, the result is a layered, umami-forward blend that demands to be poured on any noodle dish.

Best Light: Kishibori Shoyu Soy Sauce

Deep and complex, yet delicate and light on the tongue, Kishibori shoyu sauce remains one of the best on the market with its famously silky-smooth texture. While best consumed raw and paired with fish, a splash or two can accentuate the flavors of practically any dish, making it the condiment to have on stand-by as you’re preparing to serve a home-cooked feast. Its authentic paper packaging, adorned with Japanese characters, also makes it a thoughtful gift for the hard-to-please foodie in your life.

Best Gluten-Free: Megachef Gluten-Free Soy Sauce

Tikaram’s personal favorite hails from Thailand and has become a top choice among chefs for its ability to accommodate customers with gluten sensitivities. It is clean, aromatic and used primarily to enhance ingredients to create even bolder and more memorable flavors. Those on the hunt for a good oyster sauce will also enjoy Megachef’s beloved blue bottle that has won awards for its not-too-salty recipe with a base of smoked oysters.

Soy Sauce FAQs

The five primary ingredients of soy sauce are water, soy beans, wheat and salt, as well as a fermenting agent like mold or yeast. Gluten-free soy sauces remove the wheat, of course, and some brands incorporate preservatives to maintain freshness. There are also many geo-specific variations that vary in ingredient quantities, infusions and aging processes to achieve their resulting flavors.

The short answer is no. Since it is a fermented product, it shouldn’t require cold temperatures to preserve its quality or prevent it from spoiling. That said, if you use soy sauce infrequently, it will be best to refrigerate it so that you can extend its shelf life.

It completely depends on the brand. The more mainstream and inexpensive, the more likely it has been aged for a shorter period of time (typically five to eight months). More artisanal varieties, which can be compared to a good balsamic vinegar or a red wine like tempranillo, are aged for years to develop more complex and nuanced flavors.

Joey Skladany

Joeyis a writer/editor, TV/radio personality, lifestyle expert, former entertainment publicist and author of "Basic Bitchen."

5 soy sauces that deserve permanent spots in your pantry (2024)

FAQs

5 soy sauces that deserve permanent spots in your pantry? ›

Ideally, though, you'll want to pick a soy sauce with no added MSG and as pure in flavor as you can get, such as San-J Tamari Soy Sauce and other Asian Cooking Sauces. After your purchase, experiment with several kinds of soy sauce as you test new healthier snacks and dishes at home.

What kind of soy sauce is healthiest? ›

Ideally, though, you'll want to pick a soy sauce with no added MSG and as pure in flavor as you can get, such as San-J Tamari Soy Sauce and other Asian Cooking Sauces. After your purchase, experiment with several kinds of soy sauce as you test new healthier snacks and dishes at home.

What soy sauce has the most umami? ›

Tamari Traditional Soy Sauce

The tamari variety features some of the highest umami levels of all soy sauce types, making it popular as a dipping sauce (no other flavor additions needed), and also as a teriyaki sauce with excellent lustrous properties.

Is China lily real soy sauce? ›

Blended From Soya Based Hydrolyzed Plant Protein, Water, Sugar, Salt, Caramel, Starch, Spices, Sodium Benzoate.

Is Kikkoman soy sauce Chinese or Japanese? ›

In Japan, the home of Kikkoman, chemically produced soy sauce is a taboo. The Japanese soy sauce, sometimes referred to as 'shoyu' generally has a lower salt content and includes roasted wheat in the recipe.

What is the most common soy sauce? ›

Koikuchi shoyu is the most commonly used soy sauce in the Japanese kitchen, and it's likely what you think of when you think of soy sauce. Most major supermarket brands available in the US, like Kikkoman's All-Purpose Naturally Brewed Soy Sauce, don't indicate a type on the label, but they are koikuchi shoyu.

What are the oldest soy sauce brands? ›

The Shibanuma family has been producing soy sauce for over 320 years since 1688. Traces of the constant, unbroken business activity by the same family can be seen all over the premises.

What soy sauce do Asians use? ›

While light soy sauce is the “default” in a Chinese dish, the opposite is true in Japanese cooking, where dark soy sauce (koikuchi shoyu) is more common. If a Japanese recipe calls for soy sauce, you can usually assume it's referring to dark sauce.

What to avoid in soy sauce? ›

Soy sauce also contains wheat, which some people may be allergic to. People who have celiac disease, an autoimmune disorder caused by eating gluten, should avoid soy sauce that has gluten. Most soy sauces contain wheat, but some brands produce gluten-free soy sauces.

Is tamari better than soy sauce? ›

Which Is Healthier? Tamari and soy sauce have similar nutritional make-up, including a high sodium content, so be sure to moderate your consumption. If you have celiac disease or are sensitive to gluten, opt for tamari since it's not made with wheat (though be sure to double check labels).

Is soy sauce unhealthy as salt? ›

Is soy sauce healthier than salt? Despite soy sauce being high in sodium - about 870 mg per tablespoon - it's still substantially less than the 6,976 mg of sodium in a tablespoon of salt, which is why some people use soy sauce as a salt substitute.

What is premium soy sauce? ›

Traditionally brewed premium soy sauce, produced by the action of special strains of microorganisms on soybeans and wheat during fermentation. Tart, sweet, salty flavor with beefy, brewed notes. Higher total nitrogen (umami) than regular soy sauce. No preservatives Added.

What is the saltiest soy sauce? ›

There are two main soy sauces in Chinese cooking: light soy sauce and dark soy sauce. The light soy sauce is thinner and saltier and is used most often in cooking and dipping. Dark soy sauce is thicker, less salty, richer, and slightly sweet. It's usually added to a dish to give it a darker color.

What is the purest umami flavor? ›

Umami is easy to achieve

Proteins like pork, beef, fish, and shellfish make strong umami foundations and vegetables like tomatoes, mushrooms, and seaweeds are also high in glutamate (umami). And for the purest form of umami, sprinkle a dash of monosodium glutamate (MSG).

What are the different versions of soy sauce? ›

There are many qualities that distinguish different soy sauces. Today, we'll focus on six varieties: light, dark, tamari, double fermented, seasoned, and sweet sauce.

What is the difference between Chinese soy sauce and Japanese soy sauce? ›

The biggest difference between Chinese and Japanese soy sauce is that Japanese soy sauces are brewed with roasted wheat instead of wheat flour. Japanese soy sauce also uses a bit less salt and the final brew errs on the sweeter side.

What is the most common type of soy sauce? ›

Koikuchi shoyu is the most commonly used soy sauce in the Japanese kitchen, and it's likely what you think of when you think of soy sauce. Most major supermarket brands available in the US, like Kikkoman's All-Purpose Naturally Brewed Soy Sauce, don't indicate a type on the label, but they are koikuchi shoyu.

What is the difference between shoyu and tamari? ›

In Japan, Shoyu is the Japanese name for a soy sauce made from a mash of soybeans and wheat; and tends to be used as an all-purpose cooking soy sauce. Tamari is a wheat free soy sauce made by drawing off the liquid content of soybean miso.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Domingo Moore

Last Updated:

Views: 6201

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Domingo Moore

Birthday: 1997-05-20

Address: 6485 Kohler Route, Antonioton, VT 77375-0299

Phone: +3213869077934

Job: Sales Analyst

Hobby: Kayaking, Roller skating, Cabaret, Rugby, Homebrewing, Creative writing, amateur radio

Introduction: My name is Domingo Moore, I am a attractive, gorgeous, funny, jolly, spotless, nice, fantastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.