The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (2024)

July 25, 2022

Jalapeño poppers are a fun appetizer that will delight your friends and family alike before any dinner or barbecue. While the ingredients for the dish are generally simple–jalapeño peppers, oil, and cheese–cheese is a broad term. Recipes often recommend different cheeses, so we are here to explain why and give you our own cheese recommendations.

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (1)

Cream cheese for jalapeño poppers

Cream cheese is the most common choice for jalapeño poppers. Its neutral taste will let your jalapeño do all the popping. Smithfield Cream Cheese makes for great jalapeño poppers, and you can playfully add herbs and spices to flavor it to your taste. This opportunity to be creative is what makes cream cheese the most popular choice.

However, if you love the true taste of cheese, you might want to enjoy your favorite cheese inside your jalapeño poppers.

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (2)

Aged hard cheese in jalapeño poppers

Hard cheeses are a bit trickier to melt, and they won’t have the same texture as cream cheese, but some are packed with flavor, which will complement your jalapeño peppers. Cheddar cheese is one of the most popular choices. If you want strongly flavored jalapeño poppers, you may want to use a sharp, aged cheddar, such as Barely Buzzed. Its coffee rub gives it a kick that will match the intensity of your jalapeños. If you’re opting to make a cheese filling by melting the cheese, you may want to go for a milder cheddar, such as smooth Pour Me a Slice.

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (3)

Goat’s cheese for your jalapeño poppers

If you love goat’s cheese, you may want to try adding goat’s cheese to your jalapeño poppers. There are several options, but we highly recommend Chavrie’s Goat Cheese Logs. What’s great about them is their flexibility:you may enjoy the natural flavor of the original cheese log as-is, or you can add some spices. You can also opt for already flavored cheese logs, such as the Sundried Tomato flavor which will make for a summery treat, while the Cranberry Orange Peel flavor delivers a delicious sweety and salty experience.

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (4)

Blue cheese jalapeño poppers

Of course, blue cheese is also invited to the popper party! For a better texture, we recommend picking a creamy blue cheese, such as Saint Agur, rather than a crumbly cheese. Blue cheese will give a punch to your poppers, and is often paired with bacon to give a crunchy texture to your hors d’oeuvre.

Shop the cheeses from this article

Picture for Smithfield Whipped Cream Cheese 8oz
Picture for Smithfield Whipped Cream Cheese 8oz

Smithfield Whipped Cream Cheese 8oz

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (7) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (8) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (9) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (10) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (11) 5.00 out of 5

1 customer ratings

5 star

100.00%

100.00%

4 star

0.00%

0.00%

3 star

0.00%

0.00%

2 star

0.00%

0.00%

1 star

0.00%

0.00%

See all customers review >

Smithfield whipped cream is your perfect partner for cooking. Easily spreadable, it goes well on toasts, bagels, burgers...

Picture for Beehive Barely Buzzed 6 oz
Picture for Beehive Barely Buzzed 6 oz

Beehive Barely Buzzed 6 oz

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (14) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (15) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (16) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (17) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (18) 4.91 out of 5

11 customer ratings

5 star

90.91%

90.91%

4 star

9.09%

9.09%

3 star

0.00%

0.00%

2 star

0.00%

0.00%

1 star

0.00%

0.00%

See all customers review >

Cheddar rubbed with lavender and espresso. This rub permeates the cheese with notes of butterscotch and caramel near the rind.

Out of stock

Picture for Beehive Pour Me A Slice 6 oz
Picture for Beehive Pour Me A Slice 6 oz

Beehive Pour Me A Slice 6 oz

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (21) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (22) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (23) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (24) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (25) 4.67 out of 5

12 customer ratings

5 star

75.00%

75.00%

4 star

16.67%

16.67%

3 star

8.33%

8.33%

2 star

0.00%

0.00%

1 star

0.00%

0.00%

See all customers review >

Delicious cheddar cheese infused with Bourbon Whiskey, which gives it a sweet, creamy, complex spiciness.

Out of stock

Picture for Chavrie Original Goat Cheese Log 4 oz
Picture for Chavrie Original Goat Cheese Log 4 oz

Chavrie Original Goat Cheese Log 4 oz

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (28) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (29) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (30) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (31) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (32) 5.00 out of 5

1 customer ratings

5 star

100.00%

100.00%

4 star

0.00%

0.00%

3 star

0.00%

0.00%

2 star

0.00%

0.00%

1 star

0.00%

0.00%

See all customers review >

It's simple taste will enhance all your dishes, without overpowering them. It can be savored spread on toast, or used to garnish a board.

Out of stock

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (35) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (36) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (37) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (38) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (39) 4.60 out of 5

5 customer ratings

5 star

60.00%

60.00%

4 star

40.00%

40.00%

3 star

0.00%

0.00%

2 star

0.00%

0.00%

1 star

0.00%

0.00%

See all customers review >

This tangy cheese will bring the sun into your salads and throw a new light on your chicken pies or simply on crackers or a toasted baguette.

Out of stock

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (42) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (43) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (44) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (45) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (46) 4.70 out of 5

10 customer ratings

5 star

80.00%

80.00%

4 star

10.00%

10.00%

3 star

10.00%

10.00%

2 star

0.00%

0.00%

1 star

0.00%

0.00%

See all customers review >

This fruity option of cranberries and candied orange peel is perfect to add a sweet touch to all your entrees and salads. Perfect with salmon!

Out of stock

Picture for Saint Agur Blue Cheese Wedge 4.5 oz "2022 Gold World Cheese Award" for bundle
Picture for Saint Agur Blue Cheese Wedge 4.5 oz "2022 Gold World Cheese Award" for bundle

Saint Agur Blue Cheese Wedge 4.5 oz "2022 Gold World Cheese Award" for bundle

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (49) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (50) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (51) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (52) The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (53) 5.00 out of 5

8 customer ratings

5 star

100.00%

100.00%

4 star

0.00%

0.00%

3 star

0.00%

0.00%

2 star

0.00%

0.00%

1 star

0.00%

0.00%

See all customers review >

Saint Agur is one of France’s most famous blue cheeses. It combines the rich taste of blue veined cheeses with a unique creamy texture that melts in your mouth.

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop (2024)

FAQs

The best cheese for jalapeño poppers — Cheese Lover Shop? ›

Yes, these spicy jalapeño halves filled with melted cream cheese may seem a bit spicy at first. But you will never regret downing an order of these delicious morsels with a side of Bronco Berry Sauce®.

What kind of cheese is in Arby's jalapeno poppers? ›

Yes, these spicy jalapeño halves filled with melted cream cheese may seem a bit spicy at first. But you will never regret downing an order of these delicious morsels with a side of Bronco Berry Sauce®.

What goes best with jalapeno poppers? ›

They pair perfectly with other classic appetizers like nachos, chicken wings, or any kind of dip. Homemade jalapeño poppers are also a great warm-up for tailgate-style entrees, such as hot dogs or hamburgers. As far as sauces go, you'll love dipping these jalapeño poppers in garlic aioli, ranch, or even queso.

How do you keep the cheese from melting out in jalapeno poppers? ›

You'll want to leave your fillings in the freezer for at least a few hours, though it's even better if you have the patience and time to leave them overnight. When you're ready to cook, stuff the frozen filling into your jalapeños and proceed with your recipe as planned.

What is the cheese with jalapeño called? ›

Take smooth, mellow Monterey Jack, add bits of fiery jalapeno peppers, and you have Wisconsin Pepper Jack. This spicy combo brings excitement to your Mexican dishes, adds spark to your sandwiches, and livens up your cheese platters. Looking for delicious and unique snacks to fit your keto lifestyle?

Who makes jalapeño cream cheese? ›

Dive into immersive pleasure with Philadelphia Spicy Jalapeño Cream Cheese Spread. Made with fresh milk, real cream and spicy jalapeños for a multi-dimensional taste that adds a kick to meals and snacks. At Philly, we leave out the artificial preservatives, flavors and dyes to ensure a rich, quality flavor.

How does Papa John's make their jalapeno poppers? ›

Made with PHILADELPHIA® Cream Cheese spread on our original fresh dough and rolled up with jalapeños for a creamy kick. Baked fresh and cut into eight rolls. Served with ranch dipping sauce.

How do you get the batter to stick to jalapeno poppers? ›

A lot of recipes I found make the mistake of breading the jalapeño poppers with just a dip in milk followed by breadcrumbs, but it's hard to get a good single coat because liquids fail to stick to the pepper skin. To solve this, I do a double layer of dredging, first soaking the poppers in milk followed by flour.

Do you flip jalapeño poppers? ›

Poke the toothpick into the side of the jalapeno so it makes it easy to flip in the pan. In other words, not directly into the cream cheese part. Heat the jalapeno poppers in a large frying pan for about 5-6 minutes on each side, or until the bacon is browned and crispy.

How do you get crumb to stick to jalapeño poppers? ›

Doubling up on the milk and flour coating helps the breadcrumb to stick better to the pepper. You can use any type of unseasoned fine breadcrumbs you like, or panko breadcrumbs.

What is the base cheese for pepper jack? ›

Pepper Jack cheese is a delicious variant of the classic Monterey Jack cheese. It's a semi-soft, cow's milk cheese that has an open texture and a spicy taste. This spicy kick comes from the addition of jalapeño peppers, which are studded throughout the cheese.

Is pepperjack a melting cheese? ›

Pepper jack cheese is a semi-soft cheese with an open texture and spicy flavor from the sweet peppers, rosemary, habañero chilies, garlic, and spicy jalapeños studded in the cheese. Pepper jack melts easily, thanks to high moisture content.

What is jalapeño Jack cheese? ›

This delicious, semi-soft cheese gets its robust, rich flavor by infusing our Monterey Jack Cheese with diced red and green jalapeño peppers, then allowing it to patiently age to achieve peak flavor. Available sliced fresh in the deli.

What is jalapeño jack cheese? ›

This delicious, semi-soft cheese gets its robust, rich flavor by infusing our Monterey Jack Cheese with diced red and green jalapeño peppers, then allowing it to patiently age to achieve peak flavor. Available sliced fresh in the deli.

What cheese is on Arby's sliders? ›

About the Slider

​Little sandwich, big kick. We take diced fire-roasted jalapeños, thinly sliced roast beef, and top it off with Swiss on a soft slider bun.

What are the ingredients in Arby's mozzarella sticks? ›

Mozzarella Sticks: Low Moisture Mozzarella Cheese (pasteurized part skim milk, cheese cultures, salt, calcium chloride, enzymes), Bleached Wheat Flour, Water, Vegetable Oil (soybean and/or canola), Yellow Corn Flour, Contain 2% or less of the following: Calcium Caseinate, Dextrose, Extractives of Paprika (color), ...

What are jalapeño poppers made of? ›

Jalapeño poppers, or jalapeño bites, are jalapeño peppers that have been hollowed out, stuffed with a mixture of cheese, spices, and sometimes ground meat, and breaded and deep-fried.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Msgr. Benton Quitzon

Last Updated:

Views: 5514

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Msgr. Benton Quitzon

Birthday: 2001-08-13

Address: 96487 Kris Cliff, Teresiafurt, WI 95201

Phone: +9418513585781

Job: Senior Designer

Hobby: Calligraphy, Rowing, Vacation, Geocaching, Web surfing, Electronics, Electronics

Introduction: My name is Msgr. Benton Quitzon, I am a comfortable, charming, thankful, happy, adventurous, handsome, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.